Back Home

The EAC Reloaded

  • PDF

Hopes, challenges, opportunities and impediments - By BOB WEKESA

eac

A DONE DEAL: The five Presidents of the EAC member states sign the Protocol
The Common Market will serve a 120-million-person-plus economy when it comes into effect in July

Two-thousand-andnine was the season of optimism and a defining year for the bold new East Africa. By signing the Common Market protocol at the conclusion of tough negotiations, the presidents of Burundi, Kenya, Rwanda, Tanzania and Uganda set the region on a new wave of buoyancy. For the Common Market agreement means the longsought- after-political federation is no longer a mirage. According to a schedule of commitments, the five-nation bloc should transition to a political federation in 2015. This ideal should be achieved through a five-pronged approach beginning  with a Customs union, a common market, a monetary union and, finally, fully-fledged political integration. The first hurdle on the burgeoning regional integration path has to all intents and purposes been overcome, what with the Customs Union coming into force in January 2010, having been negotiated and agreed in 2005.

INTEGRATION OPTIMISM

The much more intricate Common Market is set to come into force in July 2010, further meshing and solidifying the currently disparate 120 million-person-plus regional economy. With two major deals struck, integration optimists are bubbling with optimism about the achievability of the monetary union by 2013. Thus far, the East African integration process is firmly on course, save for concerns about the economic prowess of the Kenyan economy, which is bigger than the Ugandan and Tanzanian economies combined. Speaking shortly after the signingof the Common Market treaty in November, President Jakaya Kikwete of Tanzania sought to allay fears of the dominance of the Kenyan economy over the rest of the partner states, citing, ironically, the meteoric growth of the Tanzanian economy since the signing of the Customs Union in 2005. Indeed, the Common Market protocol that looks to free movement of capital in the region was delayed by a couple of months on the back of Tanzania’s foot dragging over fears that the country would be the worse for wear once the more aggressive Kenyans were let loose to seek employment, acquire permanent residence and unhindered travel and secure land throughout the region.Diplomat EA has learned that with Tanzania slowing the pace of negotiations, the four remaining partners moved to agree on the Common Market with the caveat that Tanzania would join in at a later date. This seems to have spurred Tanzania into returning to the negotiating table with alacrity in July 2009.

eac2

LESSONS LEARNT

“Tanzanian negotiators were the toughest of all the negotiators, at some point I had to step in to ensure that our negotiators took a less stringent stance”, admitted Kikwete, as he took over the chairmanship of the EAC Summit from President Paul Kagame of Rwanda. The Summit is the highest organ of the Community, comprising the five presidents, and taking its cue from the Council of East Africa Community Affairs Ministers. Despite the sticking points the EAC ranks globally as the fastest integrating economic bloc. The Common Market, for instance, has been attained only a short 10 years after the signing of the Treaty establishing the East African Community on November 30 1999 by Presidents Daniel arap Moi (Kenya), Benjamin Mkapa (Tanzania) and Yoweri Kaguta Museveni (Uganda). It was therefore befitting for the community to go a notch higher as a Common Market on the occasion of its 10th anniversary celebrations. In comparison, it took a much longer period for the European Union, cited as the global benchmark of regional integration, to become a formal Common Market.

Delegates attending the celebrations were optimistic that the next decade will see the attainment of a political federation with all the attendant benefits. “The collapse of the initial EAC in 1977 was because politics and ideology took precedence over economic considerations. This time round, the Community is proceeding from laying the economic foundation as a means of achieving a political federation”, said Mr. Faustin Kananura Mbundu, Chairman of the Arushabased East African Business Council (EABC), the specialized body that enjoys observer status in the EAC Treaty and has made substantial contributions to the practical aspects of the Customs Union and Common Market. Riding on the wave of integration enthusiasm, President Museveni introduced a magnanimous angle to the placement of economic benefits ahead of the more fractious political equation during the Summit.

eac3

BUSINESS FIRST: East African Business Council trio, from (left), Chairman Faustin Kananura Mbundu, Vice Chairman Kelly Kiilu and John Bosco Rusagara,Chairman of the freight forwarders’ association in the region at the EAC 10th Anniversary celebrations at AICC

“We discovered oil recently in Uganda. This means that the region now has its own oil. I have discussed with my fellow presidents how the oil can be used for economic development in the region and how we can prospect for more oil deposits in the region”, Museveni said. Still, there are those who are cautious about the fast-paced approach to the integration process. Dick Toornstra, a director at the Directorate-General for External Policies of the European Union, holds the view that integration is a political process and therefore fragile. “EAC organs have a major impact on governance in the region and should therefore eschew the appetite to impose decisions. The people must see the benefits – the integration should be for the people, not for the leaders”, he said on the sidelines of the 10th anniversarycelebrations.

PRIVATE SECTOR-DRIVEN

Providing lessons are learned from the EU, Toornstra points out that negotiations and consultations are timeconsuming as there are many discordant cultural, economic and political issues to be factored into any integration process. So far, the subjection of the regional deals to the will of the people has been through three public rallies held at the Sheikh Amri Abeidi Karume Stadium over the last decade. It is understood that the Ambassador Juma Mwapachuled EAC Secretariat will be working on a referendum in the near future for the populace in the region to vote on the agreements so far reached. Indeed, the implementation of the Customs Union and Common Market will provide a litmus test on how agreements hammered out on paper play out in the populace. However, Mbundu says market forces are likely to override misgivings about “the common aspirations since the comparative advantages of all the countries will emerge as business  opportunities are exploited in the wider market”.

The EABC Vice Chairman, who is also a director with the Kenya Private Sector Alliance, Keli Kiilu, reckons competition for opportunities will be healthy rather than inward looking. One of the major factors spurring the steady strides made by the Community is the joining in of Rwanda and Burundi in 2007. This geographic and economic expansion of the Community has not only served to reduce the traditional rivalries between the traditional EAC partners – Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda to the conflict resolution agendain this part of the world. Burundi is particularly a major beneficiary on this score. “We have been devastated by civil war but now that we are in EAC, we have brothers and sisters to look up to for help”, said President Pierre Nkurunziza. Already, multilateral partners interested in working with the supra entity have taken the cue to enter into development agreements with the fledgling federation. Germany is of special importance in these respects, having funded peace building efforts on the regional scale as well as bankrolling the building of the EAC Headquarters in Arusha, whose foundation stone was laid on November 20 2009.

At 33.5 million between 1997 and 2008, Germany leads the pack of international supporters of EAC. Going forward, the balancing act between partner states will be severely tested. For instance, in order not to be unduly dominated by one country, the EAC Secretariat Secretary General, a Tanzanian, is deputized by three officers seconded from Kenya, Uganda, and Burundi, while the Chairperson of the Council of Ministers is Ms Monique Mukaruliza, from Rwanda. In similar fashion, leadership and composition of the institutions of the Community is spread across the region. While equity in the distribution of jobs and the goodies of the EAC is important, the danger lies in meritocracy being sacrificed at the altar of political patronage. “We have seen representatives of the different Governments pushing the agenda of their countries rather too hard in the past and this will continue as a challenge as we begin negotiations for the monetary.Unity of purpose as Common Market rolls out union and eventually the political federation”, a Tanzanian East African Legislative Assembly MP who sought anonymity said.

Over and above the EAC Secretariat – proposed for elevation into a decision-making Commission – other organs of the Community have matured since the 1999 treaty. Particularly significant is the 35-member East African Legislative Assembly (EALA), which has over the last eight years of existence anchored the Community by passing 25 diverse pieces of legislation. The feel-good effect of this was all too evident during a special session of EALA as part of the anniversary celebrations. A refrain in the speeches by the speakers of the five national assemblies was that EALA is the prototype for not only other regional bodies on the continent, but, in the words of EALA Speaker Abdiraham Abdi, – but also infused a regional perspective the Pan- African Assembly which has yet to get off the ground properly. While EALA has come of age fairly fast, it faces many challenges. “The financing of EALA work is mostly through remittances by the partner states. Much as these countries eventually pay, sometimes bureaucracies make it impossible for the remittances to be made fast enough and these delays our work”, said Reuben Oyondi, Chairman of the Kenyan chapter of the Assembly. Even where development partners – particularly the EU – support the EALA, this comes with the usual donor conditions. “The level of cooperation in the Assembly is amazing. We are equal partners despite the fact that some countries are smaller than others.

For instance, each country is represented by nine MPs regardless of the population from which we come from”, said Leonce Ndarubagiye, Chairman of the Burundi chapter of the Assembly. Whether this equality will be sustained into the future remains to be seen. Such is the bullish mood around the EAC renewal that a number of eastern Africa nations have started making entreaties to join the Community. Anarchic Somalia and next-door Ethiopia, seat of the African Union, are known to be keenly watching developments in the emerging economic bloc with intentions of joining. Observers see South Sudan, which votes in a referendum on whether to delink from the North in 2011, as a natural member of the eastern Africa bloc. Indeed, intransigent forces in the region are bound to be overwhelmed by the ongoing negotiations for a free trade area that would bring together 46 nations scattered in the EAC, the Southern Africa Development Cooperation (SADC) and the Common Markets for East and South Africa (COMESA). In the final analysis, the ‘one people, one destiny’ slogan will be as good as appreciation of the fragility of the sovereignty of the partners and promotion of the things that unite East Africans and their  far-flung catchment area.

Comments are now closed for this entry